<< Back to Research Summaries
ECHO Study Reveals Pregnant Women Are Exposed to Dangerous Chemicals Found in a Variety of Household Products
Authors: Giehae Choi, Jessie Buckley, Tracey Woodruff, et al.
Who sponsored this study?
This research was supported by the Environmental influences on Child Health Outcomes (ECHO) Program, Office of The Director, National Institutes of Health.
What were the study results?
Melamine and cyanuric acid were found in over 99% of the study participants. Four types of aromatic amines were also found in nearly all pregnant participants. Levels of these chemicals were higher among Hispanic and non-Hispanic Black participants and in those exposed to tobacco smoke. For example, levels of 3,4-dichloroaniline—a chemical used in the production of dyes and pesticides—were more than 100% higher among Black and Hispanic women compared to White women.
Footnote: Results reported here are for a single study. Other or future studies may provide new information or different results. You should not make changes to your health without first consulting your healthcare professional.
What was the study's impact?
This is the first national study to reveal that pregnant women in the U.S. are widely exposed to melamine, cyanuric acid, and aromatic amines—chemicals that may be harmful to maternal health and child development. This raises concerns for the health of pregnant women and babies.
Why was this study needed?
Chemicals like melamine, cyanuric acid, and aromatic amines are commonly used to make a variety of household products. Melamine can be found in dishware, plastics, flooring, kitchen counters, and pesticides. Cyanuric acid can be found in disinfectants, plastics, and swimming pools. And aromatic amines can be found in hair coloring, mascara, tattoo ink, paints, tobacco smoke, and diesel fumes. People can be exposed to these chemicals through the air, contaminated food, household dust, water, plastics, products that contain dyes and pigments, and many other sources.
Melamine was globally recognized as toxic after baby formula poisoning incidents in 2007 to 2008, which resulted in health problems in children including kidney stones, kidney failure, and in some cases, death. Research suggests that melamine may also be linked to reduced brain development. There is limited research on the effects of melamine on adults, although preliminary evidence suggests that it may be linked to cancer and other negative health outcomes. Prior studies on melamine were only conducted among pregnant women in Asian countries or limited to non-pregnant women in the U.S. Despite melamine’s potential harm and common use in household products, population-level exposure is not regularly monitored in the U.S.
Who was involved?
This study included 171 pregnant participants from nine ECHO cohorts located in California, Georgia, Illinois, New Hampshire, New York, and Puerto Rico. Of these participants, 40% were Hispanic, 34% were White, 20% were Black, 4% were Asians, and the remaining 2% were from other or multiple racial groups.
What happened during the study?
Researchers measured the levels of 45 chemicals in urine samples collected from participants during pregnancy. They used new methods to capture the levels of these chemicals in the urine samples, even those present in small amounts. Then, the researchers compared chemical levels across participants with different sociodemographic backgrounds.
What happens next?
Researchers are expanding on this study to look at the effects of higher exposures to these chemicals during pregnancy in over 1,700 pregnant participants and investigate whether these exposures are linked with child health outcomes.
Where can I learn more?
Access the full journal article, titled “Exposure to melamine and its derivatives and aromatic amines among pregnant women in the United States: The ECHO Program,” in Chemosphere.
Published August 30, 2022
Read More Research Summaries about Chemical Exposures and Pregnancy
Study Reveals Rising Levels of Plastics, Pesticides, and Replacement Chemicals in Pregnant Women
Author(s): Jessie P. Buckley, Tracey J. Woodruff, et al.
Effects of Metal Mixture Exposure During Pregnancy on Fetal Growth
Authors: Caitlin Howe, Margaret R. Karagas, et al.
Collaborative ECHO research led by Giehae Choi, PhD and Jessie Buckley, PhD, both of Johns Hopkins University, along with Tracey Woodruff, PhD, MPH of the University of California, San Francisco, investigates whether pregnant women are exposed to potentially dangerous chemicals commonly found in a variety of household products, including plastics, disinfectants, and products that contain dyes or pigments. Two of these chemicals, melamine and cyanuric acid, were found in over 99% of study participants, and exposure to four different types of aromatic amines were also found in nearly all participants. Levels of these chemicals were higher among participants of color and those exposed to tobacco smoke. This research, titled “Exposure to melamine and its derivatives and aromatic amines among pregnant women in the United States: The ECHO Program,” is published in
A recent review paper authored by Michael O’Shea, MD of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Monica McGrath, PhD of Johns Hopkins University, and Judy Aschner, MD of Hackensack University, and Barry Lester, PhD of Brown University’s Alpert Medical School provides an overview of the collaborative work ECHO has been doing to study and collect data on the effects of premature birth on child health outcomes. The article describes ECHO cohorts that have enrolled premature infants (born before 32 weeks of gestation) between April 2002 and March 2020, including three ECHO cohorts that are almost exclusively comprised of preterm infants. Researchers can use ECHO data to investigate the relationship between preterm birth, environmental exposures, and childhood chronic and developmental health conditions. This research, titled “Environmental influences on Child Health Outcomes: Cohorts of Individuals Born Very Preterm,” is published in
Collaborative ECHO research led by Amy Padula, PhD, MSc from the University of California, San Francisco and Rachel Morello-Frosch, PhD, MPH from the University of California, Berkeley found that many ECHO participants are motivated to engage in individual and collective action to protect their families and communities from the negative effects of chemical exposures. These findings may be used to improve report-back of chemical results and shift responsibility of chemical exposures from individuals to policymakers.
A new National Institutes of Health (NIH)-funded study found that pregnant women had been exposed to rising levels of certain chemicals, especially replacement chemicals: chemicals meant to replace other chemicals that have been banned or phased out. Many of the women had been exposed to neonicotinoids, a widely used type of pesticide.